Five-minute read
Michael L. DiamondAsbury Park Press
Hannah Walden was running out of time.
She had recently graduated from Kennesaw State University in Georgia, her lease was set to expire, and she was moving to New Jersey to be near her father and the New York job market.
So when she learned about a one-bedroom apartment in Keansburg for rent for $1,600, she didn't hesitate: She agreed to sign a lease for $1,750 a month, beating out dozens of other renters.
"I want to say I looked at dozens, borderline hundreds (of apartments) at this point," Walden, 22, said. "But narrowing it down, there were really seven or eight that would work. And only three or four of those were in my price range and close to my family. It was … extremely difficult to find a place within this area,"
Home prices too high? Nomad RVs in Toms River grows by helping van buyers live on the road
Central New Jersey's apartment market remains tight, with rent continuing to outpace inflation. In towns including Eatontown, Toms River and Ocean Township, average rent increased at least 7% from a year ago, according to the real estate company Zillow.
It means landlords continue to have the upper hand in an area where nearly a quarter of renters are considered cost-burdened, according to the National Low Income Housing Coalition advocacy group, meaning they pay more than 30% of their income on rent.
The reasons rent continues to rise:
- Demand. From 2019 to 2023, Monmouth County's population rose 3.7%, and Ocean County's population rose 8.5%. And the region's job market has been robust since the pandemic; from February 2020 to March 2024, Middlesex, Monmouth and Ocean County employment has increased 4.7%, higher than the U.S. gain of 3.8%, the Federal Reserve Bank of New York said.
- Supply. Housing permits have climbed steadily in Monmouth and Ocean counties since 2019, but the majority have been for single-family homes. In 2022, for example, multifamily permits accounted for less than a quarter of the total, the state reported. The result: Central New Jersey was the 10th-most competitive rental market last year, with nine prospective renters bidding on each apartment, according to RentCafe.
- Intangibles. The average interest rate for a 30-year fixed mortgage has climbed from less than 3% in 2020 to above 7% this year, making it more expensive for renters to buy a home. And even if they can afford it, there aren't many homes available.
Ways to save? OceanFirst slices hundreds of dollars off monthly mortgage. But can buyers find the homes?
"The demand for housing in general is just so high," said Robert Scott, an economics professor at Monmouth University in West Long Branch. "I think a number of those people would be buyers, which would put downward pressure on rent."
Renters continue to face scarce inventory and higher prices. The fair-market rent for a one-bedroom apartment this year is at least $2,000 a month in 15 out of 90 ZIP codes in Monmouth and Ocean counties, according to the U.S. Department of Housing and Urban Development.
By comparison, no neighborhoods had a fair-market rent for a one-bedroom apartment that topped $2,000 a month last year, according to HUD data.
Apartment plan in trouble: Crumbling Sandy Hook Fort Hanco*ck Officers' Row homes doomed?
Michael Gruosso, a Realtor with Keller Williams Realty in Shrewsbury, said landlords, who used to charge $1 per square foot for rent, now charge as much as $3 a square foot.
When he listed a 400-square-foot apartment for rent in Keansburg, his phone lit up so fast that he enlisted two other agents to help with the volume.
"It's three of us trying to handle it, and I see it everywhere," Gruosso said. "Anywhere we have a rental, it rents pretty quick — within the first couple of days it hits the market."
Walden wound up with the Keansburg apartment that Gruosso listed, and just in time. A moving truck was on the way from Georgia with all of her belongings. If she didn't get that apartment, she would have been in dire straits.
"This has been one of the most stressful moments of my life, basically," she said. "I graduated and was immediately thrown into trying to find a house within a month and a job. It's been rough."
Mail mess: Marlboro apartment complex letters, packages getting delivered to this neighbor's house
How much is rent rising?
1. Eatontown
ZIP code: 07724
Average rent April 2024: $2,114
Change from April 2023: 8%
2. Toms River
ZIP code: 08753
Average rent April 2024: $2,586
Change from April 2023: 7.8%
3. Ocean Township
ZIP code: 07712
Average rent April 2024: $2,678
Change from April 2023: 7%
Jersey Shore real estate: How this Wall office building became the final piece for a NJ real estate dynasty
4. Long Branch
ZIP code: 07740
Average rent April 2024: $2,933
Change from April 2023: 6.7%
5. Matawan
ZIP code: 07747
Average rent April 2024: $2,482
Change from April 2023: 5.5%
6. Manalapan
ZIP code: 07726
Average rent April 2024: $2,331
Change from April 2023: 4.4%
Work from home paradise: Why New Jersey tops the charts
7. Point Pleasant
ZIP code: 08742
Average rent April 2024: $3,076
Change from April 2023: 3.8%
8. Freehold
ZIP code: 07728
Average rent April 2024: $2,733
Change from April 2023: 3.7%
9. Red Bank
ZIP code: 07701
Average rent April 2024: $2,923
Change from April 2023: 3.5%
10. Neptune
ZIP code: 07753
Average rent April 2024: $2,802
Change from April 2023: -1.2%
Michael L. Diamond is a business reporter at the Asbury Park Press who has been writing about the New Jersey economy and health care industry for more than 20 years. He can be reached at mdiamond@gannettnj.com.